Skip to content

Insurance Claim

Understanding Home Appraisals in the Context of Insurance Claims

A home appraisal is an unbiased professional opinion of a property’s value. It’s conducted by a licensed appraiser who assesses various factors, including the home’s condition, size, location, and recent sales of comparable properties in the area.

A professional appraisal provides an objective, third-party assessment of your home’s worth. This is particularly important if you’ve owned your home for several years, as its value may have changed significantly due to market fluctuations or improvements you’ve made.

When you file an insurance claim, your insurer will typically send an adjuster to assess the damage. However, the insurance company’s assessment may not always align with the true extent of the loss. This is where an independent appraisal becomes crucial, providing an objective evaluation to support your claim.

When to Get a Home Appraisal for an Insurance Claim

  • Significant Damage. If your home has suffered extensive damage from events like fires, floods, or severe storms, an independent appraisal can help ensure all damage is properly documented and valued.
  • Disagreements with the Insurance Company. If you feel the insurance company’s offer is too low or doesn’t cover all the damage, an appraisal can provide evidence to support your case for a higher settlement.
  • Total Loss Situations. In cases where a home is completely destroyed, an appraisal can help determine the full replacement value, which may differ from the insurance company’s assessment.
InsuranceClaim Image1 GettingAppraisal

The Appraisal Process for Insurance Claims

The appraiser will visit your property to conduct a thorough inspection, documenting all visible damage and potential hidden issues. Photographs, measurements, and detailed notes form a crucial part of the appraisal report, providing clear evidence of the damage.

The appraiser will research local construction costs and property values to ensure their assessment reflects current market conditions. The final appraisal report will include a detailed breakdown of the damage, repair costs, and the overall impact on your property’s value.

Benefits of Getting an Independent Appraisal for Your Claim

An independent appraiser provides an unbiased assessment, free from the potential conflicting interests of insurance company adjusters. Professional appraisers are trained to identify both obvious and hidden damage that might be overlooked in a cursory inspection.

Appraisers use their expertise and current market data to provide an accurate valuation of the damage and necessary repairs and with a professional appraisal in hand, you’re better equipped to negotiate with your insurance company for a fair settlement.

InsuranceClaim Image2 Benefits

Types of Damage Commonly Assessed in Insurance Claim Appraisals

  • Structural Damage. This includes damage to the home’s foundation, walls, roof, and other critical structural elements.
  • Water Damage. Appraisers assess both immediate and potential long-term effects of water damage, including mold risk.
  • Fire and Smoke Damage. Beyond visible burn damage, appraisers consider smoke damage, which can affect a larger area of the home.
  • Natural Disaster Damage. Damage from hurricanes, tornadoes, earthquakes, and other natural disasters often requires specialized assessment.

The Appraisal Clause in Insurance Policies

Many insurance policies include an appraisal clause, which allows for an independent appraisal process if there’s a disagreement about the claim amount. If you’re dissatisfied with the insurance company’s offer, you can invoke this clause to initiate a formal appraisal process.

Typically, both you and the insurance company select appraisers, who then choose a neutral party (or arbitration/mediation based on your insurance policy) to resolve any material differences in the respective appraisal reports

InsuranceClaim Image3 Leveraging

Costs Associated with Home Appraisals for Insurance Claims

While you’ll usually need to pay for the appraisal upfront, this cost is often recoverable as part of your claim if the appraisal supports a higher settlement.

The cost of an appraisal is typically a small fraction of the potential increase in your claim settlement, making it a worthwhile investment and in some cases, particularly when using the appraisal clause, costs may be shared between you and the insurance company.

Utilizing the Sales Comparison Approach for Credibility

The sales comparison approach, which involves comparing the home to similar properties that have recently sold, provides a credible, market-based valuation. This approach is particularly valuable in probate proceedings as it offers a clear methodology that can be explained to beneficiaries and defended to the probate court or tax authorities if necessary.

By comparing various factors such as location, size, condition, and features of the home to those of recently sold properties, the appraiser arrives at a fair market value that reflects current market conditions. This objective method can help minimize disagreements among beneficiaries about the home’s worth.

InsuranceClaim Image4 Sales

How Appraisals Differ from Insurance Adjusters' Assessments

  • Scope of Assessment. Appraisers often provide a more comprehensive evaluation compared to insurance adjusters, who may focus primarily on visible damage.
  • Objectivity. While insurance adjusters work for the insurance company, independent appraisers work for you, providing an unbiased perspective.
  • Depth of Analysis. Appraisals typically involve a more in-depth analysis of repair costs and property values than standard insurance adjustments.

Experience the difference of HomeVault by Banks Valuation

Trusted, human-driven appraisals tailored to your needs and delivered on your schedule.